About Prime Choice Insurers

For over 15 years, we've been dedicated to simplifying Medicare for seniors nationwide. Our mission is to provide unbiased, expert guidance at no cost to you.

Our Story

Prime Choice Insurers was founded in 2008 by Sarah Mitchell, a licensed insurance agent who saw firsthand how confusing and overwhelming Medicare could be for seniors and their families. After watching her own parents struggle to understand their Medicare options, Sarah knew there had to be a better way.

Starting with a simple mission - to provide clear, unbiased Medicare guidance at no cost to seniors - Sarah began offering free consultations from her home office. Word quickly spread about her patient, thorough approach and genuine care for each client's unique needs.

Today, Prime Choice Insurers has grown to a team of 25+ licensed agents and medical professionals, but our core mission remains the same. We've helped over 10,000 seniors find their perfect Medicare plans, and we continue to provide the same personalized, compassionate service that Sarah started with.

What sets us apart is our commitment to being truly independent. We work with all major insurance carriers, which means we can offer unbiased recommendations focused solely on what's best for you, not what's most profitable for us.

Company Timeline

2008
Founded by Sarah Mitchell with a mission to simplify Medicare
2012
Expanded to serve all 50 states with licensed agents
2015
Reached 1,000 seniors helped milestone
2018
Achieved A+ BBB rating and industry recognition
2020
Adapted to virtual consultations during pandemic
2024
Celebrated 10,000+ seniors helped with 98% satisfaction

Our Core Values

These principles guide everything we do and ensure we always put our clients first.

Integrity

We provide honest, transparent advice with no hidden agendas or conflicts of interest.

Compassion

We treat every client like family, with patience, empathy, and genuine care for their well-being.

Expertise

We maintain the highest level of knowledge through continuous education and certification.

Service

We go above and beyond to ensure every client receives exceptional support and guidance.

Meet Our Team

Our licensed Medicare experts are here to guide you through every step of your Medicare journey.

Sarah Mitchell

Sarah Mitchell

Founder & Principal Agent

Licensed insurance agent with 15+ years of experience. Sarah founded Prime Choice Insurers with a mission to simplify Medicare for seniors nationwide.

Licensed in all 50 states
Medicare expert since 2008
Michael Chen

Michael Chen

Senior Medicare Specialist

Former healthcare administrator with deep knowledge of Medicare Advantage plans and prescription drug coverage. Specializes in complex cases.

Licensed in 25 states
Former healthcare admin
Lisa Rodriguez

Lisa Rodriguez

Medicaid & D-SNP Specialist

Licensed social worker turned Medicare agent. Specializes in helping dual-eligible beneficiaries navigate Medicare and Medicaid coordination.

Licensed in 15 states
Licensed social worker

Our Credentials

Our team maintains the highest professional standards and certifications in the Medicare insurance industry.

25+
Licensed Agents
Certified and licensed in all 50 states
50+
Insurance Carriers
We work with all major Medicare providers
A+
BBB Rating
Better Business Bureau accredited
98%
Client Satisfaction
Based on post-service surveys

Professional Certifications

  • State Insurance Licenses (All 50 States)
  • AHIP Medicare Certification
  • Continuing Education Credits (Annual)
  • Ethics & Compliance Training
  • HIPAA Privacy Training

Insurance Partners

We work with all major Medicare insurance carriers to ensure you have access to the best plans available in your area.

UnitedHealthcare UnitedHealthcare
Aetna Aetna
Humana Humana
Blue Cross Blue Shield Blue Cross Blue Shield

And many more regional and national carriers...

Community Involvement

We're committed to giving back and supporting the senior community beyond just insurance guidance.

Educational Seminars

Free monthly Medicare education sessions at senior centers, libraries, and community organizations.

Over 200 seminars conducted annually

Senior Advocacy

Active participation in senior advocacy groups and legislative efforts to protect Medicare benefits.

Members of 5+ senior advocacy organizations

Charitable Giving

Annual donations to senior-focused charities and support for local food banks and meal delivery programs.

$50,000+ donated annually

Ready to Experience the Prime Choice Insurers Difference?

Join thousands of seniors who have found their perfect Medicare plan with our expert guidance. No cost, no obligation, just honest advice.